Jameson Old Fashioned Recipe | Cake 'n Knife (2024)

Please note this post contains affiliate links.

A Jameson Old Fashioned is a simpletwist on the classic co*cktail recipe that’ll really surprise you! The kick of Irish whiskey with bitters, a little sugar and a splash of soda gives you a smooth drink that’ll elevate happy hour.

*welp* Did I happen to mention how much Iloathe moving?

It is basically the worst thing to have to do. And somehow, I have been doing it every year for years now… UGH.

Note: this is an updated version of the original post published on October 5th, 2015.

It’s hard enough just coordinating the details of a truck, storage, changing addresses and actually moving all of the things you own.

It’s even worse packing it all up into what feels like 10 million boxes…

Especially when you have a wall full of food props. GAH.

All you can think is, how… HOW did I accumulate all this crap? I’ve taken to irrationally tossing things inbags for donation because I don’t want to deal with packing and moving it.

Good news is I’m streamlining.

Bad news is being a food blogger means I have to pack my prop room (oh yea, it’s aroom). GAH so much packing paper...

I am having nightmares about being buried until a pile of packing paper with no way out….

Needless to say, my pans are packed away and cooking is a bit of a challenge. So it’s all about the co*cktails on Cake ‘n Knife for now!

Not just any co*cktail though… classic co*cktails.

about this Jameson old fashioned

Like a perfect old fashioned. Perfectly balanced and tasty.

In addition, the co*cktail you go to after a day of packing, multiple trips to the storage unit andan aching back.

Therefore a stiff drink is a godsend at the end of one of those days, trust me.

My love for Irish whiskeyis the foundation of this Jameson Old Fashioned.

There’s something about it (probably all that Irish blood pulsing through my veins) that is irresistible to me.

As a result, after yet another long day of prep, I will be kicking back with this guy. Cheers to the freakin’ weekend people.

It can’t come fast enough!

ingredients

Jameson – obviously, Jameson Irish Whiskey is the main ingredient for this Jameson co*cktail! Of course, if there’s a different Irish whiskey you prefer, you can also swap the Jameson out for that.

sugar cube – a classic sugar cube is all you need to sweeten the irish whiskey co*cktail. If you don’t have sugar cubes and don’t want to buy them for this drink, you can swap it for 1/2 oz simple syrup.

angostura bitters – a classic must-have for any bar cart! It’s essential in so many co*cktails, if you don’t already have it, go get it.

club soda – club soda or soda water will work just fine here! You only need a splash. You can also omit it if you prefer!

Love trying out new Jameson drinks? Be sure to check out more Jameson co*cktails like these: Jameson and Ginger | Jameson Manhattan | Irish Mule

this recipe’s must-haves

This is the one muddler I love to use that’s stainless steel! I usually like wooden ones but lately with the hoards of dishes I’ve been plagued with, the stainless steel oneis SO much easier to clean and just as effective. Plus it’s a lot easier to clean and you won’t get bits of berries stuck like you sometimes run into with the wood ones!

If you don’t have Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, you need to buy them immediately. The round sphere of ice is perfect for any co*cktail, melts slower than normal ice cubes so it doesn’t water down your drink and it looks so elegant, doesn’t it?

You’ll also want a set of co*cktail stirring spoons to stir together the Jameson co*cktail when it’s finally all put together.

here’s how to make a jameson old fashioned

muddle

In a double old fashioned or rocks glass, add the sugar cube, a couple dashes angostura bitters (you could also use a couple dashes orange bitters if you prefer!), and a splash of club soda. Muddle until the sugar is dissolved.

finish

Add ice (I prefer an extra large ice cube to using smaller ice cubes) and top with whiskey. Give everything a final stir and garnish with an orange peel. Serve.

tips for success

use a large ice cube. This helps stop the drink from getting watered down!

change up the bitters. I use angostura bitters here, but you can change things up my using orange or smoked orange bitters.
try Jameson Orange. Jameson recently came out with Jameson Orange and I have to say, it’s a lovely match for this co*cktail! If you like a touch of orange in your co*cktails (perhaps you use smoked orange bitters?), this is a fun swap to easily switch up the classic co*cktail combination in a whole new way with this orange whiskey! No, this isn’t sponsored, just a fun option to try out!

More tasty Jameson whiskey co*cktails to try: Jameson Whiskey Sour | Jameson and Ginger | Jameson Manhattan | Sparkling Whiskey Sour

what to serve this with an irish old fashioned

Obviously I am a big fan of co*cktail hour, especially when there are appetizers to go with it. Personally, I like to keep with the theme of Irish goodies here, so the recipes below are all recommendations along that train of thought.

• Need a light meal? This Irish Corned Beef Reuben Wrap is super tasty!
• Instant Pot Irish Beef Stewis a shortcut way to get your beef stew fix! Plus it’s ready in so much less time than traditional stovetop stew.
• You all know I love poutine, so of course I had to make acorned beef poutine!
• Fish and chips was my favorite meal to get in Ireland when I visited years ago, and thisbeer battered fish and chipsis the best way to get your fix right at home!

Explore more on the rocks co*cktails to try new libations to fall in love with!

Finally, if you make this irish whiskey old fashioned, please be sure to give this recipe a rating or leave a comment! I love to hear when you all make recipes, and I do take the time to respond to every single comment. Feel free to drop questions below too, if you have them!

Oh and be sure to tag me on Instagram if you make the recipe! Love being able to see these recipes come to live in your homes – it’s my favorite thing to look through those photos. It really means the world to me!