Allie K. Miller on LinkedIn: AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”. MacKenzie Price runs Alpha… | 432 comments (2024)

Allie K. Miller

Allie K. Miller is an Influencer

#1 Most Followed Voice in AI Business (1.5M) | Leading AI Entrepreneur & Advisor | Former Amazon, IBM | LinkedIn Top Voice | @alliekmiller on Instagram, X, TikTok

  • Report this post

AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”.MacKenzie Price runs Alpha School, a program that starts every morning with two hours of personalized learning with an AI system 😮Kids also learn life skills like public speaking, financial acumen, programming self-driving toy cars, and a ton of outdoor play time.There are adults in the room as “guides” (not teachers) who earn $60-100k a year.Students scored in the top 2% nationwide…but it’s doesn’t come cheap. Annual tutiution clocks in at $40k a year. Hard to imagine how this can scale out without a big change. What do you think? Do you think this represents the future of education? 🤔Follow me at Allie K. Miller and on Instagram (https://lnkd.in/e2jEHwk) for more on AI. Source: KVUE News in Austin

2,246

432 Comments

Like Comment

Steven Bosman-Romein

👤 Data Modeler | Logistics Enthusiast | Agile Scrum Master

4mo

  • Report this comment

I'm guessing that whoever came up with this, is not a parent. Any parent will tell you that teachers do A LOT MORE than drone off a curriculum. Also, kids learn A LOT MORE than "just knowledge" in school. They develop a huge amount of social skills, very often through conflict that, guess what, teachers have a huge hand in guiding them through.If you want simple proof of how bad an idea this is, watch any kid with a phone or a tablet behave. The last thing our kids need is more screen time.

Like Reply

154Reactions 155Reactions

Moriah Santiago

6th Grade Science Teacher | Empowering Future STEM Workforce

4mo

  • Report this comment

I believe that having consistent protected time could be genuinely enriching, provided a clear learning plan is in place with the guidance of educators, and students use this time for exploration, experimentation, and creating with AI. For middle school, it’s similar to classes like EAST, GT, or class passion projects where they dedicate a bit of time each day.The primary concern I have, as a public school teacher, is the potential for this approach to widen the gap between students with access to such education and those without. There are already significant disparities in students’ abilities due to varying resources. I worry that this could exacerbate the knowledge gap, especially in AI and digital literacy, ultimately creating disparities in tech skills crucial for the future workforce.Thankfully there are lots of resources out there for all educators to use such as Google’s Applied Digital Literacy Skills, Microsoft MakeCode, code.org, and various groups striving to make this learning accessible to all, not just students whose families can afford a $40k tuition. InnovateEDU and AI for Education come to mind as leaders in helping educators provide all students access to safe and responsible tech in schools.

Like Reply

8Reactions 9Reactions

Nicholas Beaudoin

AI/ML Principal @ Eviden | Instructor @ Caltech

4mo

  • Report this comment

High probability of selection bias here. Were these students from families that were already giving these kids extra attention/resources? If so, these kids would already be coming from a more advantaged group and have excelled in learning in most environments.

Like Reply

32Reactions 33Reactions

Felix Hovsepian

Former Professor of Informatics & CTO

4mo

  • Report this comment

In my opinion, this doesn't show how good AI is as a teacher, it simply exposes misalignment of the school system (and its assessment models) with modern society.

Like Reply

71Reactions 72Reactions

Jack H van Lelyveld

Enhancing individuals' work/life skills through personalised and focused training

4mo

  • Report this comment

As a pro trainer, I have never heard anything so totally absurd as AI replacing teachers and even more so regarding "teachers" who harbour these notions.The human race is doomed if teaching/training is left to so-called AI controlled teaching.I am well versed in IT Tech and lately as well in AI. I am fully aware of its strengths, and much more importantly, its limitations. Like this video clip illustrates and its claimed successes, it merely proves that kids (adults included), fare better where there are personalized attention from coaches (teachers in effect), superior/advanced training aids (aka AI, computers, access to information, etc.). These facts clearly point out the advantages of privelaged learning environments and have nothing, zilch, to do with AI replacing teachers.Case in point: Teachers are humans who advanced their knowledge and skills through studies for the purpose of teaching more humans. If AI is to replace teachers, then why bother teaching humans instead of teaching other AI- driven computer systems? AI devices need human taught skills to be designed and duilt, not the othe way round.It's only people with an AI fettish who do not really understand computers at all, who make these outlandish claims.

Like Reply

8Reactions 9Reactions

Alex Jenkins

Data Scientist at ubank

4mo

  • Report this comment

Why is it hard to imagine how to scale this? The upfront cost of building the AI (and system) paired with the limited seats available has clearly played an important role in price setting here...Stepping back and looking at the infrastructure and training needed to implement - it's basically a school with laptops (and a change in thinking/training for the teachers)... Would scale easier than schools where teachers need to know everything and teach the lessons...I still think peer learning (possibly paired with AI as well) is better and faster.

Like Reply

7Reactions 8Reactions

Chris Bates

Inspiring the next generation of engineers / Engineering Educator at Vicksburg Warren School District

4mo

  • Report this comment

AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”.I’d modify that as AI is enabling “a school with teachers” who use AI.Though I’m a teacher, I consider myself a guide on the side and not a sage on the stage. I differentiate “teachers” between traditional lecturers and current teaching as guiding students since there’s too much info for any one teacher to know and too much info for students to know which then becomes mindless regurgitation.The future belongs to those who use AI.

Like Reply

17Reactions 18Reactions

Alidad Hamidi

Ecosystem and Adaptive Organisation Development

4mo

  • Report this comment

The giveaway is how they measure the success. Did you meet your goal in 2 hours, we finish in 2 hours what other do in 6 hours... etc. All in favour of "efficiency". The founder keeps watching her watch :) when checking the young fellow putting together an Ikea set. An absolutely useless exercise for a kid that age. Learning how to FOLLOW INSTRUCRION ON A PREFABRICATED product instead of learning to come up with better questions, using their unique talent and creativity to create something insane. Learning how to empathise and teamwork. This school is making robots. Having adults as coaches is great. but the AI use and measuring the efficiency of knowledge collection broke the model and took away its goodness. Doing the wrong thing faster.

Like Reply

5Reactions 6Reactions

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

More Relevant Posts

  • Mindmarker

    1,541 followers

    • Report this post

    Can this AI powered self-serve learning model work in corporate learning and development? #learninganddevelopment #ai #aiinlearning

    1

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Pranita Oswal

    Women in AI | Driving positive changes in Artificial Intelligence

    • Report this post

    The idea of a "school without teachers" that uses AI to provide personalised instruction is intriguing. It appears to emphasise a combination of technology and human instruction, with an emphasis on practical skills and outdoor activities. The hefty tuition, on the other hand, raises concerns about scalability and accessibility, limiting its potential impact on a larger scale. The future of education may include a combination of AI-driven personalised learning and human-guided experiences, but cost and scalability issues must be overcome before widespread implementation. Great piece, I love this Allie K. Miller 🙌🏻🙌🏻

    2

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Pinar Polat

    EduCreator & Teacher Trainer on Generative AI for Education

    • Report this post

    Schools with no teachers. I was expecting that, not so soon though. And read carefully please, "teachers assisst students, make $60.000-100.000 a year. It seems te be an average salary for the USA, but out of 4 teachers, probably only one will be employed then. 🤦♀️ 👀 #technology #educationinnovation #educationalleadership #artificialintelligence #ai #teachingenglish #teachingandlearning #teachingjobs #eslteacher #efl #esl #futureinnovation #generativeai

    14

    1 Comment

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • June Yang

    Corporate Board Director | Former VP/GM Google, VMware | AI and cloud expert | Stanford GSB, UC berkeley, Caltech

    • Report this post

    Personalized education with #AI, while still early, the potential is promising

    24

    1 Comment

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Chris P.

    Experienced Educator - 30yrs | Agent of Change | Creative Excellence | Excitement through Design & Technology | Engineering | Robotics | CAD/CAM | Formula 24 and Goblin Car Racing |

    • Report this post

    Is the future of teaching fully AI based or maybe it’s just one version of the future? Will AI level the playing field for all in eduction or will it be for those that can afford it? Teaching is hard, there’s no doubt about that. It’s also hugely rewarding and nothing is quite like watching a young person grow, learn, reflect and adapt as they progress. Reflection is a key part so students can focus on their individual growth and perhaps this is where AI is most useful. A technology that can track and adapt learning to stretch the known and develop thoroughly the less well known would be a perfect use of AI. It’s what I’m looking forward too and something I would embrace to support my own teaching and the learning of my students.

    4

    1 Comment

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Michael Robbins

    Builder of human+digital learning ecosystems

    • Report this post

    The nightmare is AI replacing teaching in school buildings instead of augmenting purpose-driven learning everywhere.Chatbot teachers don't help with student agency—that begins with teens training their AI Agents to represent them for school, work, and life.#AI #education #learningpathmakers

    9

    3 Comments

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Andrew Mowat

    Co-Founder of EduSpark | Transformative Trainer & Coach, Author | AI in Education Expert | Professional Development Guru | Metacognition & Neuroscience Tragic

    • Report this post

    Love this as a (more than) viable example of reimagining education in an AI world. At its centre it redefines the role of a teacher from content expert to a leader of learning.What are your thoughts?#aiineducation #reimagineeducation #education

    30

    4 Comments

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • 🌀Dan Keldsen

    Digital Transformation Specialist / Co-Author of Best-Seller, The Gen Z Effect

    • Report this post

    If you read The Gen Z Effect (published in late 2014, but amazingly, still selling 9 years later), you know I'm a big believer that traditional K-12 education systems aren't nearly focused enough on the capabilities and interests of the learners.Adaptive learning, learning of useful, daily skills, working in small and large teams... there is so much potential that's being buried in an avalanche of "that's how we've always done it."You know, the too slow, sometimes too fast, boring way of force-feeding "knowledge" into heads without tying any of it to reality...I came here this morning to drop a note on best practices I stumbled onto today:"I feel like everyone is so obsessed with finding 'best practices' that they never consider all that means is AVERAGE practices."Which came out of Jay Acunzo's lengthy (and awesome) email this morning about becoming a great speaker.That's a great line - and I'd add that today's best practices are very often tomorrow's WORST practices. The useful life of a "best practice" is MUCH MUCH SHORTER than people who tout best practices are willing to admit.Look around at the "best practices" for video calls that existed pre-March 2020 for example. Within a few months, those best practices were clearly... well, a good bit of garbage.Stay hungry for being BETTER than the best of the average!Hat tip to good friend Stephen Shapiro for his book, "Best Practices are Stupid" - which will (I hope) bend your mind even further away from accepting Best Practices as a go to guide to life/work!

    5

    8 Comments

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • Dr. Latorial Faison

    English Professor • Consultant • VA Humanities Fellow• Award-Winning Poet & Author • Veteran Military Spouse • AWP Fellow • Tom Howard Poetry Prize • Furious Flower Fellow • Pushcart Nominee

    • Report this post

    I like the idea of using AI in the classroom as part of instruction.

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

  • John Beausang

    • Report this post

    Reframing this so it’s a way to make the most of AI to increase learning, engagement, and retention and keeping “teacher” instead of calling them “guides” would be less clickbait-y, but just as effective. The sooner schools adopt these tools and make them work within their system (or adapt the system to work with AI), the better off the kids will be. If AI is able to engage kids on an individual level during a class with 30 kids and one teacher, it could be great. It’s so impossible to match the lecture or exercise to all individual student’s levels or preferred learning method simultaneously. If AI can do that, catch some kids up while challenging those who are ready to learn more, the whole class could be engaged. The teacher can manage this process and interact with the entire class on higher-level concepts and discussions. AI would be 1000% better than the worksheet model. Meet the kids where they are on a way that best suits their path to learning and knowledge. They will need to know how to use and interact with AI tools if they are to succeed in the future workplace—in every role, in every sector. For teachers, this could be amazing. And I know, an AI phys ed teacher sounds ridiculous, but even there, think about how many adults have embraced on-demand or connected fitness options and how closely those virtual coaches and pre-configured workouts could evolve into AI-generated workouts specifically configured and constantly adapted for a person’s goals, workout time, physiological response to the exercises and current health status. It’s no longer an “if” scenario. I can easily see this fitting into the current public school system. Even if just in pilot programs at first, evaluated against core curriculum measures. Can’t wait to see where this goes for students and teachers.

    Like Comment

    To view or add a comment, sign in

Allie K. Miller on LinkedIn: AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”.MacKenzie Price runs Alpha… | 432 comments (40)

Allie K. Miller on LinkedIn: AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”.MacKenzie Price runs Alpha… | 432 comments (41)

1,415,117 followers

  • 1,389 Posts
  • 3 Articles

View Profile

Follow

More from this author

  • Get the Power of ChatGPT in Your Spreadsheets and Docs Allie K. Miller 1y
  • ChatGPT and The Professional's Guide to Using AI Allie K. Miller 1y
  • The Startup's Guide to Building Machine Learning on AWS Allie K. Miller 4y

Explore topics

  • Sales
  • Marketing
  • Business Administration
  • HR Management
  • Content Management
  • Engineering
  • Soft Skills
  • See All
Allie K. Miller on LinkedIn: AI is enabling a “school with no teachers”.

MacKenzie Price runs Alpha… | 432 comments (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 6220

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.